The pub is the institution visitors most want to experience and the one where quality varies most unpredictably. Two pubs a hundred metres apart can be entirely different propositions, and the signals that distinguish them are learnable in about five minutes.
What are the reliable signs of a good pub?
Local people in it, at times when tourists would not be. A short menu rather than a laminated one covering forty dishes. Cask ale being pulled regularly rather than standing.
Also: someone behind the bar who knows what they are serving, no music so loud that conversation is impossible, and a room that has not been refitted to look like every other pub in the chain.
How do you judge the beer?
Cask ale is a living product with a short shelf life once broached, so turnover matters more than choice. Three well kept ales beat eight standing half sold.
Ask for a taste, which any decent pub will offer without hesitation. A beer that is flat, vinegary or cloudy when it should not be indicates poor cellar work, and if one is off the others may be too.
What is the difference between a freehouse and a tied pub?
A freehouse can buy beer from anyone, which usually means a more interesting and locally sourced range. A tied pub is owned by or contracted to a brewery or pub company and must buy from them.
Tied does not mean bad, and several brewery estates run excellent pubs. It does explain why the beer range is what it is.
How do you judge the food?
By the length of the menu and how specific it is. A short menu that changes and names its suppliers indicates a kitchen cooking. A long menu covering every cuisine indicates a freezer and a microwave.
Specials written on a board in handwriting are usually a good sign. So is a pub that stops serving food at a specific time rather than all day.
What guides are worth using?
The Campaign for Real Ale publishes an annual guide to pubs serving well kept beer, compiled by local volunteers, which remains the most reliable single source for beer quality.
Various national awards cover pub food. Locally, asking anyone who lives there produces better results than any list.
What should you know about opening hours?
Rural pubs frequently close on Mondays and Tuesdays and may not serve food on Sunday evenings. Many close in the afternoon between lunch and evening service.
This catches out visitors constantly, particularly on walking trips. Check before relying on a pub for a meal, especially out of season.
What are the different types?
The community local, which serves its neighbourhood and may do little food. The food led pub or gastropub, effectively a restaurant. The country inn with rooms. The historic pub, trading partly on its building.
Each is good at something different, and the mistake is expecting a serious meal from a wet led local or a good pint from a place focused entirely on dining.
What is pub etiquette?
Order and pay at the bar unless told otherwise, and wait your turn without pushing forward, since bar staff generally remember who arrived when. Rounds are common in groups.
Tipping bar staff is not expected, though offering to buy them a drink is traditional. Table service has become more common since it was introduced during the pandemic and varies by pub.
What should you avoid?
Anywhere on a high street with photographs of the food outside, anywhere with an enormous menu and no specials, and anywhere completely empty at a time when it should not be.
Conversely, a pub with an unpromising exterior and a full bar of regulars at Sunday lunchtime is almost always worth going into.
What about pubs with rooms?
A particularly good option for anyone touring, since it removes the drive after dinner entirely. The best combine a serious kitchen with simple bedrooms upstairs or in a converted outbuilding. Ask which rooms are above the bar when booking, since noise until closing is the main risk, and check which days the kitchen serves, as many rural inns close early in the week.