Back to Attractions

What Makes a Proper Sunday Roast?

What Makes a Proper Sunday Roast?
British Travel Guides Editorial 2 March 2026

The Sunday roast is the meal most worth planning a British weekend around, and it is also the meal where standards vary most wildly. A good pub roast is one of the best things you can eat in this country; a poor one is reheated meat and a frozen Yorkshire pudding.

What is actually on the plate?

A roasted joint, usually beef, lamb, pork or chicken. Roast potatoes. A Yorkshire pudding. Seasonal vegetables. Gravy. Plus accompaniments matched to the meat: horseradish with beef, mint with lamb, apple sauce and crackling with pork, stuffing with chicken.

Cauliflower cheese, pigs in blankets and honey roast parsnips appear at better places and are the sign of a kitchen making an effort.

What separates a good roast from a poor one?

The potatoes, more than the meat. Properly roasted potatoes are crisp and rough edged outside and fluffy inside, which requires parboiling, roughing up and hot fat, usually dripping or goose fat. A pale, smooth potato indicates a kitchen taking a shortcut.

Then the gravy, which should be made from the roasting juices rather than a powder, and the vegetables, which should not be boiled to extinction.

Is the Yorkshire pudding compulsory?

With beef, traditionally yes, and most pubs now serve it with everything. In Yorkshire it was historically served first, alone with gravy, as a cheap filler before the meat, and some places still do this.

A good one rises dramatically and is hollow. A dense flat disc has been made from a mix or reheated.

When is it served?

Sunday lunchtime, typically from noon until the meat runs out, which at popular pubs can be by half past two. Some serve into the evening; many do not.

This is the most important practical point. Turning up at three expecting a roast is a common disappointment, and phoning ahead is worth the minute.

Should you book?

Almost always, particularly at any pub with a reputation, and several days ahead in popular areas. Sunday lunch is the busiest service of the week for most British pubs.

Booking also means the kitchen knows how much meat to cook, which is why the good places take reservations and run out anyway.

What is a carvery?

A different format, where you queue at a counter and a chef carves to order with unlimited vegetables. It is usually cheaper and generous, and the quality is variable.

Carveries suit large groups and big appetites. A plated roast from a kitchen cooking one or two joints properly is usually better food.

How do you find a good one?

A pub with a short menu that changes, a kitchen that lists its meat supplier, and a Sunday menu offering three or four joints rather than eight. Local recommendations beat national lists.

Avoid anywhere offering roasts seven days a week, which almost always means reheated portions rather than a joint cooked that morning.

What about vegetarians?

Better catered for than a decade ago. A good pub offers a proper vegetarian or vegan roast with a nut roast or a substantial alternative, cooked with the same care, plus vegetarian gravy.

Ask when booking rather than on arrival, since some kitchens need notice and vegetarian gravy is frequently the thing forgotten.

What should you drink with it?

Whatever you like, though a pint of cask bitter with a beef roast is the traditional pairing and works better than people expect. Red wine with beef and lamb, cider with pork.

Leave time afterwards. A proper Sunday roast is not a meal to eat before an afternoon of driving, and a walk is the correct next activity.

What is the history of it?

The tradition is generally traced to meat roasted after church, and to the practice of leaving a joint at the baker's oven during the service. Yorkshire pudding began as a way of catching dripping and filling people up cheaply before the meat arrived. Knowing that explains the shape of the meal, which is built around making a modest amount of expensive meat feed a household generously.