Scotland has around ninety inhabited islands and they differ enormously in how remote they feel, how much there is to do and how much effort they take to reach. Choosing the wrong one for a first visit usually means either spending the holiday travelling or finding there is less to occupy you than expected.
Which is the easiest to start with?
Arran, reached by a fifty five minute ferry from Ardrossan, itself under an hour by train from Glasgow. It is often described as Scotland in miniature, with mountains in the north, gentler farmland in the south and a road running right round the coast.
It has a good range of accommodation and food, a castle, distilleries, standing stones and proper hill walking on Goatfell. For a first island trip with limited time, it is the strongest choice.
What does Mull offer?
More drama and more space. Mull is large, mountainous and reached from Oban in under an hour. Tobermory is the most photographed harbour town in Scotland with its row of coloured buildings.
It is also the gateway to Iona, with its abbey and its role in bringing Christianity to Scotland, and to Staffa, where basalt columns form Fingal's Cave. Mull has excellent wildlife, including white tailed eagles, otters and whale watching trips.
Who should choose Islay?
Anyone interested in whisky. Islay has a remarkable concentration of working distilleries for an island of its size, most offering tours, and the peated style produced here is distinctive enough to have its own following.
It is also flat, good for cycling, has fine beaches and holds enormous numbers of wintering geese. The ferry from Kennacraig takes just over two hours, and flights run from Glasgow.
How does Skye compare?
Skye is the most visited and the most dramatic, connected by bridge so no ferry is needed. The Cuillin, the Quiraing and the Trotternish ridge are unmatched.
It is also the most crowded, with real pressure on parking and accommodation between June and August. As a first island it can give a misleading impression of what Scottish islands are like, since almost everywhere else is far quieter.
When should you choose Orkney?
When the archaeology is the draw. Orkney is greener, flatter and gentler than the Hebrides, with the finest Neolithic sites in Britain and substantial Norse and wartime history.
It takes longer to reach, requiring either a long drive north or a flight, and it feels more like a farming community than a wilderness. Visitors expecting mountains are sometimes surprised.
Which should you avoid for a first trip?
Not avoid exactly, but leave until later: the Outer Hebrides, Shetland, Jura, Coll and the small isles. These take a day of travel each way, have limited accommodation and few facilities, and reward a week rather than a long weekend.
They are among the best places in these islands and they suit a second or third visit far better than a first one where you are still learning how ferries and island logistics work.
What should you consider before booking?
Whether you need a car, since vehicle spaces book out months ahead in summer. What there is to do in poor weather, which on the smaller islands may be very little. How many nights the travel justifies, with a rough rule of two nights minimum for every hour of ferry crossing.
Book the ferry first, the accommodation second and plan the itinerary last. Islands reward a slow trip, and the most common regret is having allowed only two nights somewhere that deserved five.
How much does an island trip cost?
Less than most people assume. Ferry fares on many routes are set at roughly the equivalent cost of driving the same distance, which makes crossings inexpensive. Accommodation is the main expense and is limited enough on the smaller islands to hold its price even out of season. Self catering and camping both reduce the cost substantially, and access to the landscape is free.