Three generation holidays have become common in Britain, driven by the cost of large properties being lower per head and by grandparents providing childcare that lets parents have an actual break. They work extremely well or badly, and the difference is almost entirely down to the building rather than the people in it.
What does the accommodation need?
More than one sitting room, without exception. The whole model depends on people being able to be in different places at once, and a single open plan space forces everyone into the same activity at the same volume.
Also: bedrooms spread across the property rather than clustered, so early risers and late sleepers do not disturb each other, and more than one bathroom.
What should you check about accessibility?
Whether there is a ground floor bedroom and bathroom, which matters for older relatives and is far less common in converted rural properties than the photographs suggest.
Also the approach: steep drives, gravel, uneven thresholds, steps up to the front door and open staircases all cause problems that only become apparent on arrival. Ask specifically rather than relying on a listing describing itself as suitable for all.
How do you split the cost?
Agree it before booking, in writing, including who pays for what beyond the accommodation. Food, activities and eating out are where the awkwardness arises rather than the rent.
A common approach is to split accommodation by household rather than by head, and to run a shared kitty for food that everyone contributes to at the start.
How much time should be spent together?
Less than groups expect. One shared meal a day and one shared activity every couple of days is usually the right level. Attempting to do everything as a group of nine produces friction quickly.
Building in an expectation that people will split off, rather than treating it as a defection, removes most of the tension before it starts.
What is the childcare arrangement?
Worth discussing openly beforehand. Grandparents often expect and enjoy having the children; they may not expect it every evening for a week without being asked.
Agreeing a couple of specific evenings in advance is better for everyone than an assumption that becomes an obligation by the Wednesday.
Where should you go?
Somewhere with variety within a short radius, so different subgroups can do different things without long drives. Coastal areas work well, as do market towns with countryside around them.
Avoid anywhere requiring a demanding walk to reach anything, since it excludes the youngest and oldest simultaneously. Somewhere with a beach, a level walk and a pub within reach covers most of the group most of the time.
What about the journey?
Different households will arrive at different times and from different places, which needs coordinating with the property's check in arrangements. Key safes make this straightforward; a meeting with an owner does not.
Consider whether older relatives are comfortable driving the final approach, particularly on single track lanes or steep drives.
How long should it be?
A week is usually right. Long weekends are dominated by arrival and departure, and anything over ten days with nine people in one house tests most families.
Building in one day where everyone does something separate, roughly midweek, resets the group noticeably.
Is it worth it?
For most families, yes, and it is one of the few holiday formats where the cost per person falls as the group grows. It also produces the kind of week children remember for a long time.
The risk is entirely in the accommodation. Booking a house that is too small or too open plan for the number of people is the single mistake that turns a good idea into a difficult week.
It is also worth agreeing in advance who is responsible for the practical side: the food shop, the cooking rota and the final clean. These are small things that cause disproportionate friction when they land on the same person every day without anyone having discussed it.